In other words, we read it more as an act of good faith of the sort that. Pdf on mar 1, 2011, allan franklin and others published alan sokal. Letter to the editor cold fusion and the sokal affair i would be far more cautious than allan d. The reader probably knows about the famous sokal affair.
Back in the 1990s the physicist alan sokal published a nonsense article in a postmodern journal. Harrell ii 12 n otices of the ams v olume 43, number 10 the oamsrpdaaas official ams representa. After a short summary of the sokal affair and of the point of view of steven weinberg, we discuss certain aspects of the scientist ideology present in the last book. As strathausen 1994, 69 indicates, millers article is tough going for the reader not well versed in the mathematics of set theory. The sokal affair is overdetermined by four currents.
Alan sokal submitted several pages of gibberish to a journal called social text, to see if it would be published. In the wake of the furious support sokal gleaned from what has become known as the sokal affair, he has published a book, with jean bricmont, entitled fashionable nonsense. The sokal hoax, also known as the sokal affair, was a publishing hoax perpetrated by alan sokal, a physics professor at new york university. Pdf in this little nontechnical piece, i argue that some of the lessons that can be learnt from the bold action carried out in 1996 by the physicist.
What the new sokal hoax reveals about academia the atlantic. A report from the front of the science wars the controversy over the book higher superstition, by gross and levitt and the recent articles by sokal evans m. Retrieved march 5, the article is a masterpiece of foggy prose. I think it will be clear to the reader which passages are written in a liberatory postmodern spirit and which are written by means of malicious and. Some lessons for us scientists too from the sokal affair. This refers to an illumi nating action designed and carried out by alan sokal in. Impostures intellectuelles, published in the uk as intellectual impostures, is a book by physicists alan sokal. In 1996, sokal submitted an article to social text, an academic journal of postmodern cultural studies. Sokal on the social text affair transgressing the boundaries. Papers by alan sokal on the social text affair transgressing the boundaries.
Editorial response to sokal hoax by editors of social text pdf. In 1996, sokal, a professor of physics at new york university, submitted a paper of nonsense camouflaged in jargon for publication in social text, as an experiment to see if a journal in that field would, in. Sokal, the reply from the social text editors, the response from stanley fish and the discussions in the nation, the times higher education supplement, tikkun and recently, the times literary supplement. I will argue in this essay that in the sokal affair. Papers by alan sokal on the social text affair sokal bricmont book.
Sokal squared doesnt just expose the low standards of the journals that publish this kind of dreck, though. Hoaxes of exposure are semicomical or private sting operations. The sokal affair in context stephen hilgartner, 1997. Science, philosophy and culture find, read and cite. The sokal affair was a hoax by physicist alan sokal perpetrated on the editorial staff and readership of the postmodern cultural studies journal social text published by duke university. Article information, pdf download for a rhetorical perspective on the sokal hoax. Kindle ebooks can be read on any device with the free kindle app. Sokal s phone number, address, insurance information, hospital affiliations and more. What the social text affair does and does not prove, by the physicist, alan sokal what the sokal hoax ought to teach us, by the philosopher, paul boghossian sokal s hoax, by the physicist, steven weinberg the sleep of reason, by the philosopher, thomas nagel. Not to mention the skeptic society and skeptic magazine and any other skepticatheist leader that promoted this as nothing other than a publicity stunt by two academics spouting a political agenda as extremist as what they are failing to attack.
David mermin, i mentioned that one of the great ironies of the sokal affair was seeing physicists police math abuse when, among mathematicians, fairly or not, physicists used to have the reputation of. Yet the relation between the sokal affair and this longer history is by no means obvious. In 1996, new york university professor of physics alan sokal wrote a parody of an. The irony of physicists policing mathematics abuse. Pdf some lessons for us scientists too from the sokal affair. Alan sokal imposturas intelectuais pdf the reception of the sokal affair in francepomo hunting or intellectual mccarthyism a propos of impostures intellectuelles by a. Read derridas response to the sokal affair critical.
Full text of the sokal hoax see other formats 1 morten tolboll the sokal hoax the sokal hoax, also known as the sokal affair, was a publishing hoax perpetrated by alan sokal, a physics professor at new york university. Alan sokal is an american physicist and mathematician. Toward a transformative hermeneutics of quantum gravity in the postmodern journal social text. The search for possible mechanisms of lowenergy chemicallyinduced nuclear transformations is not necessarily a. If sokal was hoping to spur a serious discussion of academic rigor. Franklin newsletter, september 1999 in branding cold fusion as bad science. I have lost all respect for michael shermer, peter boghossian and james lindsey. Impostures intellectuelles, published in the uk as intellectual impostures, is a book by physicists alan sokal and jean bricmont. Pdf some lessons for us scientists too from the sokal.
On the inside, while his teaching was developing, lacan made diverse references to mathematics, logic, philosophy, linguistics, history. Sokal is best known for the sokal affair, in which he submitted a deliberately absurd article to social text, a critical theory journal, and was able to get it published. Skeptic reading room the conceptual penis as a social. The discussion to follow assumes on the reader s part a general but. Immediately afterwards he revealed the paper to be an elaborate hoax engineered to expose the bankruptcy of postmodernist discourse about science. The episode has often been offered as evidence for the bankruptcy of a broad and diverse collection offields, variously referred to as cultural studies of science, sociology of science, history of science, and science and technology studies. The stuff of 10 years ago is the eponymous sokal affair, when he dropped a bomb on postmodern literary theory and social science by publishing a parody paper, transgressing the boundaries. Sokals articles and further commentary can be found at the sokal affair. More reference than ripping good yarn, the sokal hoax is a document of unintended consequences. He came to prominence for the eponymous sokal hoax.
The failure to consider the sokal affair in light of other, related episodes has contributed to a wholesale misreading of its significance. The difference is that sokals hoax served a public purpose, to attract attention to what sokal saw as a decline of standards of rigor in the academic community, and for that reason it was disclosed immediately by the author himself. Where are we, how did we get here, and can we get home. It also demonstrates the extent to which many of them are willing to license. Sociologist stephen hilgartner, the cornell university science and technology studies department chairman, wrote the sokal affair in context24 comparing sokal s hoax to confirmational response. Lacan provokes a certain number of written pieces including sokal and bricmonts which do not send him back to the undifferentiated mass, and he provokes others yet.
He is best known for his criticism of postmodernism, which implies strongly that the proverbial emperor of postmodernism may indeed have been naked all along. The sokal affair also sokal s hoax was a hoax by physicist alan sokal perpetrated on the editorial staff and readership of the postmodern cultural studies journal social text published by duke university press. In 2009, cornell sociologist robb willer performed an experiment in which undergraduate students read sokals paper and were told either that it was written. Sokal felt their emphasis on relativism surrendered the intellectual high. In addition to these particular debates, this selection also includes various commentary available on the. Not to mention the skeptic society and skeptic magazine and any other skepticatheist leader that promoted this as nothing other than a publicity stunt by two academics spouting. This list includes the original hoax article from prof. After a short summary of the sokal affair and of the point of view of steven weinberg, we discuss certain aspects of the scientist ideology present in the last book of alan sokal pesudoscience ans postmodernism. Also included are extended essays in which a wide range of scholars ponder the longterm lessons of the hoax. How was the academic response to the sokal affairsokal. How was the academic response to the sokal affair sokal hoax. Towards a transformative hermeneutics of quantum gravity in the journal socialtext. Deconstructionists read things like social text, which.
The sokal affair and the history of criticism authors. Read derridas response to the sokal affair august 27, 20 eugene wolters 17 comments in 1996, alan sokal, a physicist at nyu, decided to troll postmodernism by submitting a paper to a wellregarded journal that was complete and utter bullshit. Imposturas intelectuales sokal pdf imposturas intelectuales sokal, a y bricmont, j free ebook download as pdf file. That doesnt mean that social sciences, literature, and art have nothing important to say. This article has become quite influential in film theory. He seemed to be trying to prove that if your article use enough jargons in postmo writing, even when the article makes zero sense, it would still be accepted as an academic contribution. In 1996, sokal, a professor of physics at new york university, submitted a paper for publication in social text, as an experiment to see if a journal in that field would, in sokal s. Sokal is best known for the sokal affair, in which he submitted a deliberately absurd article to social text, a critical theory journal, and was able to get it fashionable nonsense. The targets of sokal s satire occupy a broad intellectual range. The sokal affair, also called the sokal hoax, was a demonstrative scholarly hoax performed by.
303 147 750 466 719 348 1554 512 544 493 442 549 283 1673 816 1550 758 510 1337 128 1264 606 1426 521 717 557 250 1628 717 1208 240 690 1190 1419 1140 1068